Historic Preservation and Urban Density

Things got confused very early on. Somebody said: Those multi-family developments destroy character of historic neighborhoods. Developers scrape old homes to erect duplexes. We need to stop multiplex developments to preserve urban communities. Somebody said: Density is the enemy of our lifestyle. And others nodded in agreement.

Things got confused because what we are discussing here are two separate issues: historic preservation and density. Historic preservation makes a distinction between structures that are historically significant and need to be preserved and the ones that have outlived their utilitarian lifespan and should be replaced with new buildings. Density adds value to the urban lifestyle by creating walkable communities supported by public transportation.

The two issues are separate but not mutually exclusive. We need both historic preservation and density to ensure health of our neighborhoods. Limiting density will not protect historic homes. We can’t treat a headache by putting both legs in a cast.